An Author’s View on the 2018 Cocky Kerfuffle

I was a bit dumbfounded when I stumbled into Facebook drama earlier this week. It was from a fellow indie author who was talking about something with the hashtag #cockygate. Curious, I inquired about it and was shocked to find out that an indie Romance author by the name of Faleena Hopkins trademarked the word “cocky.”

So instead of reacting like a spoiled, self-indulgent millennial that I occasionally am, I decided to do some research into it and figure out what was happening. That of course meant that I went directly to YouTube and entered into the search bar “#cockygate.”

Of course, I should mention that this isn’t the first time someone has tried to do this. The Fine Brothers, creators of Fine Brother’s Entertainment or better known for the React Channel on YouTube, attempted to do this with the word “react” back in 2016. Less than a week later, the brothers rescinded all trademarks for the word due to pressure from the internet.

Watching this current situation, I’m not sure Hopkins will follow the Fine Brother’s example.

If you take a look at the trademark claim, which you can look it up at and search for “cocky,” you’ll see that the trademark is only for the stylized font of the word and not the word itself. So theoretically, Hopkins should only be issuing copyright claims if an author was using this trademarked style. It’s similar to if I would try to publish a book with Disney’s styling of words.

Except, it’s gone a bit off the rails. It’s been reported that authors who are using the word “cocky” in their titles, not the trademarked stylized version, are receiving takedown notices. To get an excellent explanation, better than what I could do, watch the video by mundanematt. He does a good job of explaining the matter.

Some of you might be thinking what’s the problem. Because it won’t end with Hopkins trademarking the word “cocky.” There are reports of someone trying to trademark the word “rebellion.” What’s next? If these trademarks aren’t dealt with then no word is safe.

My books have a theme to them. They all start out “The Book of…” and then finish with the main character’s name. They’re in the horror genre, but there’s a biblical theme to them, you get the idea. What happens if someone trademarks the word “book?” Will I be sent one of these take down notices and forced to either change my titles or hire a lawyer? I’m not rich like Stephen King or James Patterson and cannot afford to do either.

What Hopkins is attempting to do is just plain terrible. It takes time and money to change your book title. You also have to think about the marketing aspect. Your readers have to be informed that you’ve changed your title.

Help spread the word with this awesome T-Shirt!

It’s also disgusting. Imagine being a chef. You’ve just started this great job at a restaurant. It’s your life’s dream. Then another chef from a different restaurant walks in and picks up your secret ingredient that you use in your specialty recipes. “Sorry, but I’ve banned anyone else from using this ingredient. You’ll just have to use something else.” Because you’re new at being a chef, you don’t want trouble from the more experienced chef that’s opened up 17 restaurants in the past so you use another ingredient. It’s not as good, but you have to make do without that key ingredient.

Words are ingredients for authors. They combine them with others to form intricate recipes called novels. Now, because of this cocky kerfuffle, we can’t use the word “cocky” in our titles. Hopkins has crippled her fellow chefs. In her video defending herself, she doesn’t see any issue in what’s she’s doing. In the new Avengers: Infinity Wars (2018), Thanos didn’t see any issue in what he did either. Hopkins snapped her fingers and disintegrated one word from existence.

Just let this sink in: Villains always believe they’re doing the right thing.

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like
Love Love
Geek Out Geek Out
Geek Out
Sad Sad
Angry Angry
James Master

A natural born reader, James tackled the works of Stephen King and Michael Crichton when he was in the sixth grade. His influential young mind, now twisted by the science fiction and horror genre, James did what any respectable young man would. He began crafting stories. Instead of playing in recess, James would write stories about dinosaurs and serial killers. He hasn’t stopped writing or reading which is where his path crossed with Burning Willow Press, LLC. Ironically enough, you can find James’s first published work, “The Dark Forest,” in the anthology “Crossroads in the Dark II: Urban Legends” published by Burning Willow Press. His first book, “The Book of Roland” published Feb. 25, 2017, is a 2017 Summer Indie Book Award nominee. It is the first of seven in the Soul Eater Chronicles and it is centered around a katana wielding, gunslinging, pop culture referencing monk named Timothy as he fights the incarnations of the Seven Deadly Sins. His next book, “The Book of Mark”, is scheduled to come out early 2018. James graduated from Indiana University South Bend with a Bachelor’s degree in English and a Minor in Film Studies in 2015. By day, James works as a mild-mannered reporter for The Pilot News as well as an editor for the weekly paper The News-Mirror. By night, he works for BWP reading submissions or writing his own works.
Choose A Format
Personality quiz
Series of questions that intends to reveal something about the personality
Trivia quiz
Series of questions with right and wrong answers that intends to check knowledge
Voting to make decisions or determine opinions
Formatted Text with Embeds and Visuals
The Classic Internet Listicles
The Classic Internet Countdowns
Open List
Submit your own item and vote up for the best submission
Ranked List
Upvote or downvote to decide the best list item
Upload your own images to make custom memes
Youtube, Vimeo or Vine Embeds
Soundcloud or Mixcloud Embeds
Photo or GIF
GIF format
Send this to a friend